I´ve got some nodes with TinyLora deployed. Trying to migrate one of those to V3 results in some Problems. Nodes with TinyLora dont accept downlinks and they cant process MAC requests. But it seems in V3 downlinks with MAC requests are essential? Or have they alwas been there in this amount and I c…

[image] greensladenz: Suggesting people buy new hardware ISN’T a solution. It is, however unpalatable - particularly as it represents an opportunity to upgrade / improve. People can swap out devices, putting in something better for much less than the original cost - and then repurpose the ol…

[image] clv: What if we send a device status answer every 10 uplinks? Tried that and it wasn’t succesful. The application keeps sending downlinks also after the 10th uplink. It might also be a bug that needs to be corrected. Maybe in the same category as “resets-f-cnt” which is also not worki…

[image] descartes: It is, however unpalatable Shouldn’t that be it isn’t , however unpalatable… for the reasons you list? :thinking:

No**, suggesting people buy new hardware IS a solution. I was rebutting the ISN’T It is a solution. Like telling people to use carrier pigeon or Clacks . ** the No here is rebutting your suggestion.

[image] rvdvoort: Below is the response of the CLI and ahow the new node is created. Please don’t post screenshots of code and logs. See: How do I format my forum post? [HowTo]

[image] greensladenz: If I can’t make use of TinyLoRa then I guess I’m not using TTN anymore. That’s unfortunate - TinyLoRa has never really been suited to use, but more as a crude proof-of-concept. That said, I can see where you are coming from A lot of the replies here seem really gateke…

So what does this mean for us amateurs with stateless TinyLora/Arduino sensors, using ABP and not caring about Frame Counter Checks and MAC Downlink Commands? I mean we support TTN with own gateways as much as we can but if we need to change our entire hardware just for some compliancy needed for i…

[image] niels80: So what does this mean for us amateurs with stateless TinyLora/Arduino sensors, using ABP and not caring about Frame Counter Checks and MAC Downlink Commands? Nothing yet - it’s too early to say given the measured evaluation and testing that needs to be done and maybe some ch…

[image] descartes: save the gateway fruitlessly transmitting an ADR request. It is important that once network realises node is being antisocial and ignoring such requests it stops adding to the problem by spamming downlinks - makes situation worse! I hope TTi adapt the stack to support this,…

Is V3 the end for TinyLora?

TTN V2 to V3 Upgrade V3 Devices

bluejedi February 7, 2021, 4:20pm 69

Please don’t post screenshots of code and logs. See: How do I format my forum post? [HowTo]