@htdvisser In the Console Live data view of my V3 gateway I see that each received uplink message is forwarded twice. My gateway is ‘LoRa Basics Station’ based. [Image 2021-02-18 15·17·50] Comparing the Event details of both forward events does not give much information. Why is each received u…

[image] bluejedi: Why is each received uplink message forwarded twice? The uplink is forwarded to the Network Server in the cluster, and to Packet Broker. It should be possible to add those details to the event. I created Add `host` to `gs.up.forward` event data · Issue #3827 · TheThingsNetw…

[image] htdvisser: The uplink is forwarded to the Network Server in the cluster, and to Packet Broker. Why is it forwarded to packet broker? (TTN V3 does not route to TTN V2.)

It could be peered traffic from a private TTI deployment registered node that is picked up by a TTN GW then routed through PacketBroker to TTI hence the forwarding… the GW is transparent and just passing packet through and only TTN back end will know for sure if it is a TTN or TTI node so to avoid l…

[image] Jeff-UK: It could be peered traffic from a private TTI deployment registered node that is picked up by a TTN GW then routed through PacketBroker to TTI hence the forwarding It is traffic from my own V3 device arriving on my own V3 gateway that gets forwarded twice to the next link in …

[image] bluejedi: Maybe there is brokering from TTN V3 to private V3 instances Exactly - system cant wait for a decision of “is this Jeff’s node talking through Jeff’s GW to Jeff’s application in TTN V3 Application server?” before deciding nope it’s for a TTI private instance that has peering…

Similar “problem” (triple message) with GW status. [image] V3.11.0-rc1 - Multiple GW status messages are normal? Gateways Just testing for V3. On fist message “correlation_ids” > “gs:up:host” attribute is missing. On last two messages the atttribute “gs:up:host” is prese…

I assume that display is UI from your gateway and not TTN Console? I’m not sure what the “Receive gateway status” means, but I only see two ‘forward’ events, not three. (‘gateway status’ means message?)

[image] bluejedi: assume that display is UI from your gateway and not TTN Console? TTN V3, gateway console. GW periodically sends a Json about statistics, but in TTN console it appears every time x3 times.

[image] bluejedi: Why is it forwarded to packet broker? In all The Things Stack (v3) deployments managed by The Things Industries, all traffic is forwarded to Packet Broker. The routing policies in Packet Broker then determine if and where that traffic gets routed. [image] bluejedi: Mayb…

[image] htdvisser: In all The Things Stack (v3) deployments managed by The Things Industries, all traffic is forwarded to Packet Broker. The routing policies in Packet Broker then determine if and where that traffic gets routed. I see a reasonable number of packets arriving on my gateways wit…

Why is uplink message forwarded twice by V3 gateway?

TTN V2 to V3 Upgrade V3 Gateways

clv (clv) February 18, 2021, 8:04pm 7

Similar “problem” (triple message) with GW status.